Best Hallmark Mysteries of 2025
Hallmark continues to be the gold standard for cozy mysteries, and 2025 was an especially delightful year for fans of gentle whodunits and comforting crime.
From beloved returning sleuths to fresh mystery franchises, this year’s lineup had everything cozy mystery lovers crave—small-town settings, clever clue-solving, charming characters, and mysteries that focus on puzzles over peril. In this list, we’re rounding up the best cozy mysteries Hallmark had to offer in 2025, so you can easily find your next feel-good mystery movie or series to curl up with.
7. Pie to Die For: A Hannah Swensen Mystery
Pie to Die For: A Hannah Swensen Mystery serves up another small-town whodunit with Lake Eden’s favorite baker at the center of the action. When a murder shakes the community, Hannah Swensen finds herself following a trail of secrets, rivalries, and carefully hidden motives—while still keeping her bakery running. The story leans into smart deduction, familiar relationships, and the comforting rhythms that fans of the series know and love.
Why cozy mystery lovers will enjoy it: This installment keeps the focus on puzzle-solving and community dynamics rather than danger or grit, making it a strong pick for cozy mystery fans. The food-centric setting adds warmth and personality, while Hannah’s hands-on sleuthing and the town’s web of suspects create a satisfying, low-stress mystery. Pie to Die For is ideal for viewers who enjoy Hallmark mysteries that feel comforting, character-driven, and gently suspenseful without ever losing their cozy appeal.
6. Mystery Island: Winner Takes All
Mystery Island: Winner Takes All drops viewers into an exclusive island getaway where a competitive event turns deadly—and everyone becomes a suspect. As tensions rise and secrets surface, sharp observation and clever deduction are the only way to untangle what really happened. With its contained setting and classic whodunit structure, this Hallmark mystery leans into twists, motives, and misdirection rather than dark or gritty crime.
Why cozy mystery lovers will enjoy it: The closed-circle suspect list and puzzle-forward storytelling make this a treat for fans of traditional cozies. There’s suspense without brutality, smart sleuthing over action, and a stylish but comforting Hallmark tone that keeps the mystery engaging without ever feeling heavy.
5. Mystery Island: Play for Keeps
Mystery Island: Play for Keeps ups the stakes with a new case where rivalry, ambition, and long-buried grudges collide on Mystery Island. As alliances shift and hidden agendas come into focus, the investigation unfolds through character interactions and carefully revealed clues, rewarding attentive viewers who love to play armchair detective.
Why cozy mystery lovers will enjoy it: This movie shines for fans who enjoy mysteries driven by interpersonal drama rather than danger. The island setting adds escapist charm, while the emphasis on motives and relationships delivers a satisfying, low-stress whodunit perfect for cozy mystery audiences.
4. Mystery Island: House Rules
Mystery Island: House Rules leans into classic mystery tradition as the rules of the island—and the people who enforce them—come under scrutiny after a shocking crime. With a tightly woven suspect pool and layered secrets, the story invites viewers to question every interaction as the truth slowly emerges.
Why cozy mystery lovers will enjoy it: This installment is ideal for viewers who love thoughtful, clue-based mysteries with a polished Hallmark feel. There’s no graphic content, just methodical sleuthing, elegant twists, and an immersive setting that keeps the tone cozy while delivering a rewarding mystery payoff.
3. Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery
Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery is a cozy Hallmark mystery that brings beloved baker-sleuth Hannah Swensen back into the middle of another deliciously puzzling case. When a murder disrupts a high-profile food-focused event, Hannah must juggle her bakery, her personal life, and a growing list of suspects as she follows the clues—one smart deduction at a time. Familiar faces, small-town charm, and culinary coziness make this a comforting entry in the long-running Hannah Swensen Mystery movie series.
Why cozy mystery lovers will enjoy it: This movie is tailor-made for fans of classic cozy mysteries—an amateur sleuth, a tight-knit community, and a mystery that unfolds without graphic violence or dark themes. With its baking backdrop, gentle humor, and character-driven storytelling, Reality Bites: A Hannah Swensen Mystery offers comforting escapism and satisfying sleuthing. It’s especially appealing to viewers who love Hallmark mysteries, food-themed cozies, and whodunits where charm and clever clues take center stage.
2. Mistletoe Murders - Season 2
Mistletoe Murders Season 2 returns to the festive town of Fletcher’s Grove, where charming Christmas shop owner Emily Lane once again finds herself wrapped up in murder investigations hiding beneath twinkling lights and holiday cheer. As secrets surface and old wounds reopen, the new season deepens the mystery while expanding the show’s cozy world, blending small-town intrigue, seasonal atmosphere, and clever sleuthing into a binge-worthy Hallmark mystery series.
Why cozy mystery lovers will enjoy it: Mistletoe Murders Season 2 delivers everything fans of cozy mysteries crave—an amateur sleuth, a close-knit community full of secrets, and puzzles that rely on observation and deduction rather than violence. The Christmas setting adds an extra layer of comfort and charm, making it perfect for viewers who love holiday mysteries, gentle suspense, and character-driven storytelling. It’s a modern cozy mystery series that feels festive, warm, and satisfyingly smart.
Signed, Sealed, Delivered to the Moon and Back
Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back is a heartwarming Hallmark mystery that reunites the beloved POstables—Oliver, Shane, Rita, and Norman—as they unravel a deeply personal case tied to a lost letter and a life-changing decision. Blending gentle mystery, emotional stakes, and signature charm, this installment continues the series’ tradition of thoughtful storytelling, clever clues, and heartfelt connections, all wrapped in Hallmark’s cozy, feel-good style.
Why cozy mystery lovers will enjoy it: This film is perfect for fans who prefer comfort mysteries over crime-heavy plots. There’s no graphic violence—just smart problem-solving, endearing characters, and a puzzle rooted in human relationships. With its small-team sleuthing, warm humor, and emotional payoff, Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To the Moon and Back checks all the cozy mystery boxes while offering the soothing, uplifting vibe Hallmark fans crave.